Out of Nothing. What's that mean?

[mikebnllnb]

Originally Posted by granpa

yes there has to be a beginning.
no there doesnt have to be a point where there was "Nothing"

Why does there have to be a beginning?

If we look at suns and solar systems many begin from the end of a previous star. The universe could work the same way. This universe could be the latest in a long line of universes. Without beginning or end.

If there doesn't need to be "nothing" at some point then there is no beginning.

If "nothing" is an impossibility and I say it is. Then so is a beginning.

[granpa]

no

[mikebnllnb]

Originally Posted by granpa

no

A well thought out and deeply intellectual response. Thank you.

[rifleman]

Originally Posted by mikebnllnb

A well thought out and deeply intellectual response. Thank you.

I agree, mike! Sure beasts me on being concise and brief. I no can do, unfort.

But at least it sets a goal for me! One-word answers! Yikes!