Quote:
Originally Posted by Suzsilk
The original post was about how working longer could be conducive to better health, and personally I disagreed. Work, for me, was challenging and stressful. Sometimes I had to manage large groups of children--up to 135--at the same time. Sorry if a different opinion, with some examples to show a different point of view, is so offensive. Retirement is great and no one should be afraid to retire because they think it means they're going to die a slow death or that their health is going to deteriorate. You health in retirement is up to you.
|
Which is why I think headline correlations like these are extremely misleading, at best.
My mother is pushing 300 pounds at 5'2, has a myleodysplastic syndrome, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, type 2 diabetes, and a range of other health issues. She's going to the doctor, on average, one to two times per week. She'll be 60 this year. I wouldn't say she seems "elderly," but she is in poor health. She was at a general practitioner Monday, a hematologist yesterday, and will be going to the ophthalmologist Thursday.
She's likely to retire when she reaches 62 and take SS. If she's still around at 70, one could imply from the article's conclusion that she'd have been healthier had she kept working longer, which may be true, though not because "work makes you healthy." For people like her, work is the only thing not keeping them from vegetating in front of the TV all day and being even more sedentary.
Her father was much the same way, though he had significant heart issues in his 50s. He was "old" in his early 60s. Once he retired, he had no defined schedule, nothing to keep him accountable, and become less and less willing, then less able, to do anything. I don't know if it shortened his life or not, but I don't think he would have been any worse off had he taken up a lighter schedule with a hobby, volunteering, or easy, part-time work.
There are plenty of professions where work breaks the body down, but plenty of others that do not. My mother works in loan documents at a local bank. It's office work. She hasn't followed medical advice to improve her diet (lunch was a Burger King Whopper and dinner was Arby's yesterday), get more active, lose weight, and generally take better care of herself. Her habits account for a far greater portion of her health outcome than simply working or not working.