Which of these rings do you think would be a better deal? (expensive, purchases)

[Jays1983]

Originally Posted by Jill61

Actually, the awkward letdown happened when he started out by asking me if I wanted to live together -- something I'd made perfectly clear from the beginning that I was unwilling to do -- but before I could say a word, his mother walked into the room and interrupted! (We were visiting his family in Denmark for the holidays.)

While he went over to ask her to scoot so we could have some privacy, I was desperately trying to figure out how I was going to say no and not hurt his feelings. Then when he came back, he proposed marriage, so at that point I didn't really care what kind of ring he'd given me. He later claimed he was so nervous that he was trying to work his way "up" to the actual marriage proposal and it came out all wrong the first time. I guess I have his mother to thank. Love you, mom!

Lol, "wanna live together". It's good things worked out though.

[Jill61]

Originally Posted by Jays1983

Lol, "wanna live together". It's good things worked out though.

Indeed it is. He's the best.

[Kleenex]

Options:

#1 .58 Ct, colorless (F), I(1), round set in white gold $1800 after taxes

#2 .50 Ct, colorless (F), I(1), round set in white gold $1400 after taxes

#3 .48 Ct, nearcolorless (H), I(2), round set in white gold $1000 after taxes


All are certified.

one from Kay, one from Shaws, one from Zeals

[spiderbear]

Of the choices? 3.

I have better things to spend money on.

[njguy]

#4 - One made out of a twist tie.

No need for insurance either and is easily size adjustable without a jeweler getting $ involved.

[Raena77]

neither I would want platnium

[Jill61]

Huh? I thought you already had a thread about this?

[Mercury Cougar]

I would choose no ring at all. I'd rather have a nice honeymoon trip to remember than a ring for which I paid two or three times the true value.

[Raena77]

Originally Posted by Mercury Cougar

I would choose no ring at all. I'd rather have a nice honeymoon trip to remember than a ring for which I paid two or three times the true value.

Hell yeah I agree!!!

[Kleenex]

#1, 2, or 3 please!

if your answer is 'neither' or any option other than the 3 above, you are either not paying attention to the question or have no valuable information for me. just move on!