I agree. When we bought our starter home a few years ago we thought we'd worry about schools when we got to that bridge. When it came time to upsize, we decided to stay in the district. I met so many local families who were very happy with the schools and now that we've been in 3 years, I can say I'm very happy as well. We definitely have a large immigrant population which probably affects the test score since they are testing in a second language, but my husband likely did the same when he came here at age 6 and he went on to the Ivy League and a great job. It's not all about test scores and ratings.
The schools also had a history of a large achievement gap for the minority students, but they started some innovative programs and have seen great success in narrowing the gap. Here's a great article:
Once racially troubled, a district shrinks the achievement gap | Hechinger Report
We also love the community pride that is here, there is a great library, great farmers market, parks, etc. I will be honest and say there are some less than ideal parts of town, but its only a few streets and you can easily tell as soon as you get in the area (and a decent realtor wouldn't show you a house in that area).