Can anyone here suggest a great game for us to get?

[Yac]

Originally Posted by skins_fan82

Fallout 3 and/or Fallout: new Vegas will absolutely change your life. They changed mine. Crude, yet hilarious humor, cool shooting and guns, open world concept that lets you go anywhere you want, anytime you want.

This is true, while Skyrim might be bigger and prettier, the open world fallout games have a unique feel and the plots are great (well, F3 not that much, NV is significantly better). It's a game that has quests, characters and encounters you'll remember for a long time, while for me personally, Skyrim seemed a bit too repetitive after a while (though still very fun).
Yac.

[skins_fan82]

Agreed, Yac. Fallout New Vegas can playout differently every time you play, depending on the decisions you make. That's what I enjoy so much about the Fallout and Skyrim games, there's literally 100+ decisions you can make as you go along that can totally change how things play out.

Choose to help one side, help the other side, or help no one. You can save somebody, or let them die. you can build your character to be good, neutral, or evil, and the people you come across in the game will react to you based on your character's personality.

[lovesthebass]

Originally Posted by dave nz

We just finished GTA5 and wanting to get another game.

Heres what we are after :

-Fighting and shooting all good
-Humor a must, some humor at least
-Reasonably challenging
-And all round a well thought of and respected game

Has to be a game for the PS3

Thanks for reading and I hope someone can help!

I second Borderlands 2 + DLC. It pretty much achieves every one of your requirements.