If you are looking to stay in the Concord, Harrisburg area-Afton Village is really the only community that "looks" like Baxter Village, although I may be forgetting one. Which church are you going to be attending? I know Crossroads is right down the way from Afton Village-my BIL attends church there.
Here are a few other communities that offer homes that are unique and many are by custom builders:
Bradford Park
Abbington
Morris Glen
Maple Bluff
Fenton-Dell
Clarehaven
Flowers Farm
Stallings Glen
Not all of the neighborhoods are pool communities.
In Huntersville, I would also check out MacAulay...really pretty homes with narrow streets, big front porches, etc. Definitely a pool there! Charlotteagent probably has more info on the Huntersville area than I do since I live in Concord.
I will tell you that if you do an MLS search on the neighborhoods I listed for the Harrisburg/Concord area, you won't find that many available. These are desirable neighborhoods and homes don't usually sit for very long. I live in one of the neighborhoods above and homes usually sell within 30 days-I swear all we get in the mail are detailed lists of current listings/pending sales/recently sold homes!
Some of the neighborhoods may have lots available to build a new home on, though.
Let me know if you have any questions!
Good luck,
Nicole