I ended up trying
Gazy Brothers farm, they deliver to a wide area from Fairfield Co to New Haven. Delivery was the biggest factor as our schedules are very unpredictable right now. We only have had one week so far (summer), but the produce was fresh, flavorful and decent variety. Good portions for the single box for 2 omnivores. Price was a bit higher than some others we were looking at, not organic (though they say they practice IPM/integrated pest management), delivery is an additional cost. Glad to be supporting local businesses where possible.
I now buy my eggs from a farm stand <2 miles away as needed. They're fresher than store eggs, but I doubt they're organically fed (other than what the chickens can find free-ranging).