...where exactly would you live, and why?
States
Alabama
Kentucky
Michigan
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
New Mexico
North Carolina
Ohio
Oklahoma
Pennsylvania
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
West Virginia
Sections of states
California (northern)
California (southern)
Florida (outside of Miami area)
Illinois (downstate)
New York (upstate)
Virginia (outside of Washington DC area)
I'll start...
Alabama - Auburn. It's a college town that's only an hour and a half drive from Atlanta, and it seems less prone to tornadoes than Birmingham, Huntsville or Tuscaloosa.
Kentucky - Bowling Green. It's a college town about an hour from Nashville, and it's home to GM's Corvette plant.
Michigan - Grand Rapids. It'll soon become Michigan's second major metropolitan area (1,000,000+ population), and it gets a lot of snow in the winter.
Mississippi - Hattiesburg. It's a college town about an hour from the Gulf Coast and an hour and a half from New Orleans.
Missouri - Columbia. It's a college town about an hour from the Lake of the Ozarks, and an hour and a half from Kansas City, St. Louis, and my extended family in northern Missouri.
Montana - Billings. It's the largest city in a thinly-populated state, half a day from the spine of the Rocky Mountains, and a day from Denver and the Twin Cities.
New Mexico - Clovis. I like the name of the town, and it's not far from Amarillo or Lubbock.
North Carolina - Charlotte. I've always enjoyed my time in Charlotte, and the Raleigh area is too decentralized for my liking. It's only three hours away from Athens, four hours from Atlanta, and seven hours from Pittsburgh.
Ohio - Columbus. It's a major metropolitan area with a college town vibe, and it's only an hour and a half from Cincinnati, two hours from Cleveland, and two and a half hours from Pittsburgh.
Oklahoma - Tulsa. It doesn't seem quite as tornado-prone as Oklahoma City, and it's only an hour from there, two hours from the Ozark Mountains, and three hours from Kansas City.
Pennsylvania - Pittsburgh. It's home.
South Carolina - Greenville. It's a rapidly growing city that's an hour from Asheville, an hour and a half from Athens and Charlotte, and two hours from Atlanta and the Great Smoky Mountains.
Tennessee - Nashville. I've visited all four large cities in Tennessee, and Nashville is the one that I felt most "at home" in.
Texas - San Antonio. Not as humid or as prone to hurricanes as Houston, not as prone to tornadoes as Dallas/Fort Worth, and not as prone to smug as Austin. The Riverwalk is a great place to spend time.
West Virginia - Weirton. It's essentially an exurb of Pittsburgh at this point, and I can still get Pittsburgh radio stations clearly there, unlike in Morgantown.
California (northern) - Fremont. Sacramento and San Jose didn't do much for me, and the East Bay (minus Berkeley) seems more easy-going and less snooty than San Francisco.
California (southern) - Anaheim. Seems pretty centrally located in the greater Los Angeles conurbation, with easy access to the big city and the beaches of Orange County, plus a straight shot east to I-15 if I ever want to go to Las Vegas.
Florida (outside of Miami area) - Jacksonville. It's the least prone to hurricanes of all the cities in Florida, and big enough for there to be things to do. It also has some underrated beaches, and it's just three hours from Orlando, and six hours from Atlanta and Miami.
Illinois (downstate) - Belleville. It's a suburb of St. Louis, only four hours from Chicago and Nashville, and less than a day's drive from Athens.
New York (upstate) - Syracuse. It's a college town that's an hour from Rochester, two hours from Buffalo, and four hours from Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, New York and Toronto. It also gets plenty of snow.
Virginia (outside of Washington DC area) - Charlottesville. It's a college town with lots of history nearby, and it's only an hour from Richmond, two hours from Washington DC and Virginia Beach, and five hours from Pittsburgh. And the best Southern food I've ever had was at the Michie Tavern.