04162014, 06:40 PM



3,890 posts, read 5,327,376 times
Reputation: 2622


Hi,
i have a 10 year mortgage that was refinanced exactly 1.5 years ago. We currently have 6 years left on the mortgage but we're paying very aggresivly and are on track to be done in 1.5 years.
The current loan amount is 143k. The rate is 3.25%. Monthly payment is 3100 but we pay 9200 a month.
I got an offer a couple of days ago for a refi option.....called them up yesterday and here's the deal: 3/1 ARM, rate 2.24%, $300 total closing costs.
I haven't done the detailed calculations...but at 1% less than my current rate, i guesstimated that we'd save about 12001500 in interest in the 1.5 years until we pay off the loan (same schedule as we're on now). take into account the 300 bucks closing, and i'd come out ahead by about a thousand give or take.
what are your thoughts?
Do it? or not?

04162014, 06:57 PM



Location: N/A
849 posts, read 1,675,587 times
Reputation: 930


Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinkingman
Hi,
i have a 10 year mortgage that was refinanced exactly 1.5 years ago. We currently have 6 years left on the mortgage but we're paying very aggresivly and are on track to be done in 1.5 years.
The current loan amount is 143k. The rate is 3.25%. Monthly payment is 3100 but we pay 9200 a month.
I got an offer a couple of days ago for a refi option.....called them up yesterday and here's the deal: 3/1 ARM, rate 2.24%, $300 total closing costs.
I haven't done the detailed calculations...but at 1% less than my current rate, i guesstimated that we'd save about 12001500 in interest in the 1.5 years until we pay off the loan (same schedule as we're on now). take into account the 300 bucks closing, and i'd come out ahead by about a thousand give or take.
what are your thoughts?
Do it? or not?

NO. you are self amortizing...quit messing with it. No way they are closing that with a traditional mortgage for $300 without rolling additional principal into your loan.

04172014, 10:46 AM



Location: SoCal desert
8,092 posts, read 13,895,775 times
Reputation: 14907


Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinkingman
Refinancing to a 3/1 year ARM .... Should i do it?
Hi,
i have a 10 year mortgage that was refinanced exactly 1.5 years ago. We currently have 6 years left on the mortgage but we're paying very aggresivly and are on track to be done in 1.5 years.

To me, it wouldn't be worth the hassle.

04172014, 11:26 AM



Location: MMU>ABE>ATL>ASH
9,211 posts, read 18,342,162 times
Reputation: 10166


+1 Not worth Hassle..
There are going to be hidden fees. (FedEx Overnight fees, Notary fees, Recording fees etc)
Do you need to take a vacation day off for the closing? (How much is that worth)
Don't for get to you can claim the interest on your taxes, so the $1000 you "save" is even less.

04172014, 11:45 AM



Location: Long Island
9,441 posts, read 20,254,455 times
Reputation: 5155


NO!
For a possible $1,000? Which may turn into nothing if unexpected fees pop up?
I commend you on your diligence in paying almost three times the required amount. Stick with what you have.

04172014, 12:36 PM



Location: Mount Laurel
4,182 posts, read 10,078,998 times
Reputation: 3488


Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinkingman
Hi,
i have a 10 year mortgage that was refinanced exactly 1.5 years ago. We currently have 6 years left on the mortgage but we're paying very aggresivly and are on track to be done in 1.5 years.
The current loan amount is 143k. The rate is 3.25%. Monthly payment is 3100 but we pay 9200 a month.
I got an offer a couple of days ago for a refi option.....called them up yesterday and here's the deal: 3/1 ARM, rate 2.24%, $300 total closing costs.
I haven't done the detailed calculations...but at 1% less than my current rate, i guesstimated that we'd save about 12001500 in interest in the 1.5 years until we pay off the loan (same schedule as we're on now). take into account the 300 bucks closing, and i'd come out ahead by about a thousand give or take.
what are your thoughts?
Do it? or not?

Something is not right with your math. If you have a $143K balance and paying $9200/month over the next 18 months, that's a total of about $165K in payment.
Refi to 2.24% (assuming it's amortized over 30 years) and you continue to pay $9200/month, you will be paying a lot less (A little over $2200 in interests) and it would not take you 1.5 years to pay it off either (16 months)
Last edited by sj08054; 04172014 at 12:40 PM..
Reason: correction

04172014, 12:46 PM



3,890 posts, read 5,327,376 times
Reputation: 2622


Quote:
Originally Posted by sj08054
Something is not right with your math. If you have a $143K balance and paying $9200/month over the next 18 months, that's a total of about $165K in payment.
Refi to 2.24% (assuming it's amortized over 30 years) and you continue to pay $9200/month, you will be paying a lot less (A little over $2200 in interests) and it would not take you 1.5 years to pay it off either (16 months)

Well, first off, a portion of the 9200 goes towards Taxes, Insurance, and Interest. Only about $8100 is being reduced from the principle each month...multiply by 18 and you get roughly $145,782
The refi to 2.24% is over 4 years....3/1 ARM....at the current pace, over the next 18 months, i'll be paying 3600 in interest......with the 2.24% rate, i suspect i'd be paying around 2300 or so as you estimated......

04172014, 01:06 PM



Location: Mount Laurel
4,182 posts, read 10,078,998 times
Reputation: 3488


Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinkingman
Well, first off, a portion of the 9200 goes towards Taxes, Insurance, and Interest. Only about $8100 is being reduced from the principle each month...multiply by 18 and you get roughly $145,782
The refi to 2.24% is over 4 years....3/1 ARM....at the current pace, over the next 18 months, i'll be paying 3600 in interest......with the 2.24% rate, i suspect i'd be paying around 2300 or so as you estimated......

So you are paying $1100 a month for taxes,insurance and interests? But that doesn't matter if your number is correct in that you have 18 more payments to make at the current terms to pay off your mortgage. You are paying a total of about $165K
If you took out a new loan @ 2.24% (doesn't matter if it's 3/1 or 5/1, chances are it amortized over 30 years). Not sure what you mean when you say 2.24% is over 4 years. With the new loan with principal payment of $8100/month, your total interests is about $2500.

04172014, 01:08 PM



3,890 posts, read 5,327,376 times
Reputation: 2622


Ok, i called to confirm things with them....
here are the details:
2.24% for 3 years fixed. 4th year it'll be Prime + 0 but no more than 2 points increase in a year (so...max 4.24% the fourth year)
$300 includes everything. ALL costs. The title company will be local.
I'm trying to Justify NOT doing it....lol
Quote:
Originally Posted by sj08054
So you are paying $1100 a month for taxes,insurance and interests? But that doesn't matter if your number is correct in that you have 18 more payments to make at the current terms to pay off your mortgage. You are paying a total of about $165K
If you took out a new loan @ 2.24% (doesn't matter if it's 3/1 or 5/1, chances are it amortized over 30 years). Not sure what you mean when you say 2.24% is over 4 years. With the new loan with principal payment of $8100/month, your total interests is about $2500.

I misspoke....it's not "over 4 years". it's amortized over 10 years.

04172014, 01:18 PM



Location: Vallejo
15,837 posts, read 17,815,481 times
Reputation: 14264


Normally I'd say absolutely not, but if it's only going to cost $300 in closing costs and no points, maybe. You'd save $900 or so if your calculations are correct. I didn't check them. That's probably worth it. On the other hand, you have flexibility now. Since my income is variable, I would not do it.

Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: Citydata.com.

