Quote:
Originally Posted by tongpa-nyi
Given that we can't test this empirically, I guess the best we can do is debate using speculation and educated guesswork. So, what say you in response to what I've said?
|
interesting response but I could point out some flaws in your hypotheses. First off, atheists tend to look for logical reasons for everything they believe. If an atheist starts having hallucinations or hearing voices talking to them, they are not likely to jump to the conclusion that god or satan is speaking to them. Assuming they (or those near them) question the origin of the voices/hallucinations, they're probably going to start from the assumption that they should get checked out by a professional.
On the other hand, a religious person will be a lot more likely to immediately assume that they're possessed by demons or that their god is talking directly to them. In looking back through many past and current threads on these boards, this seems to be very much the case. Someone claims to be possessed by a demon, or claims to be having divine "visions" and the immediate reaction of most of their religious compatriots is to encourage them in their delusions without question.
Conversely, when a nonbeliever sticks his head into one of those many threads and suggests (however politely) that the person suffering the delusions should get medical evaluation to rule out illness, that person without fail seems to get viciously attacked by those religious people. Go scan back through some of the
threads that have "visions", "possessed/possession", "demons", et cetera in the titles and you will see what I mean.
It seems to almost always be a non-religious person that suggests medical evaluation first, whereas the religious will fall for any declaration of possession or "divine visions" without so much as a pause to think about it's validity first.