Critique (not grade) the fictional climate above you and then optional post your own fictinal climate (hot, warm)

[ABrandNewWorld]

Critique (make a list of things that are good and bad about it but do not give a letter grade) the fictional climate(s) above you. Then optionally post your own fictional climate:
(note: there was another thread about doing this with real climates but I can't find it).


Here's mine:

[EverBlack]

Originally Posted by ABrandNewWorld

Critique (make a list of things that are good and bad about it but do not give a letter grade) the fictional climate(s) above you. Then optionally post your own fictional climate:
(note: there was another thread about doing this with real climates but I can't find it).


Here's mine:

Winters are too warm, summers are too hot and it's too sunny. I like the precipitation.

[jgtheone]

Originally Posted by EverBlack

Winters are too warm, summers are too hot and it's too sunny. I like the precipitation.

D-

Winters are too cold, and it's a rapid transition to a humid summer. Bleh.

I could have sworn there was a thread like this before, but meh.

[Ed's Mountain]

Originally Posted by ABrandNewWorld

Critique (make a list of things that are good and bad about it but do not give a letter grade) the fictional climate(s) above you. Then optionally post your own fictional climate:
(note: there was another thread about doing this with real climates but I can't find it).


Here's mine:

Second response in and people are already giving a letter grade instead of critiquing.

Nevermind, fictional climates are kind of boring anyway IMO. Here's the link to the one with real climates if anyone's interested.

//www.city-data.com/forum/weath...above-you.html

[jgtheone]

Originally Posted by Ed's Mountain

Second response in and people are already giving a letter grade instead of critiquing.

Nevermind, fictional climates are kind of boring anyway IMO. Here's the link to the one with real climates if anyone's interested.

//www.city-data.com/forum/weath...above-you.html

My bad.

I don't mind fictional climates, as long as they're within the realms of possibility.