My teenage son went to Realm of Darkness and said it was really good. McCall's is really good, too. They added a new attraction this year called "Zombie Hunt" where people sit in the back of a truck and shoot at zomibies that are in a make-shift town. The other night-time attractions are the Haunted Barn and the Haunted Cornfield. My kids go every year. By now though the lines will be super long (like hours) unless you pay extra for a fast pass. In the future, plan on going at the end of September or the first weekend in October when the prices are a little cheaper, the weather is not as chilly, and the lines aren't as long.
Mccall's Haunted Farm | New Mexico's Most Terrifying Haunted Attraction