Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
We all know that each city has many places with reviews. I want to use that to see how popular a city is using it's population and the total added amount of reviews the places in the city has
I know that bigger cities will have more reviews, so I want to know how I can scale the reviews with the population to figure out if a city is popular or not.
I will be using the city of Plymouth WI as an example. The first 20 places that showed up when I typed "Plymouth WI Things To Do" have the combined total of 8518 reviews, while the population is 8923 people. How might I scale this to measure popularity?
I apologize if this makes no sense. I am in a rush to do something, so I had to type this out as fast as possible
Please define your terms. "Popularity" might mean how often something is visited, or it might mean how many five-star reviews it got. What exactly are you trying to measure?
I usually do Google Things To Do and I add a +1 for every attraction with at least 1,000 reviews. That often gives me a good barometer of popular attractions, and then I can tell how many days to spend there (usually 1 day for 5 sights. So a city with 20 sights is 4 days).
I think adding up the top 20-25 is an interesting thought experiment though. But Google doesn't show you the Top 20 most reviewed sights. They show you the top sights based on an algorithm. So a place with 50,000 reviews and 4.6 stars might be #30 whereas a place with 10,000 reviews and 4.9 stars is Top 5 in their rankings.
I would also say it biases against touristic cities that don't have a ton of people. By your metric, Houston is a more popular city than New Orleans and Houston Zoo and the Galleria are far more popular than any sight in New Orleans.
In reality, New Orleans is the far more popular tourism city. It's just that Houston has 7 million natives and they'll eventually get around to visiting the Zoo and the Mall and writing a review.
Not sure if Google searches necessarily correlate to popularity. I'm sure when the Boston Marathon explosion happened, "Boston" was a more popular search term than New York.
One needs to utilize appropriate resources for varying situations. I find for instance Google less reliable for restaurant reviews where I'll utilize TripAdvisor or Opentable which have more experienced and (in my opinion) reputable reviewers than say Yelp, which is notoriously skewed toward reviews like where "the hostess was mean to me/one star" or "our party of seventeen with no reservation for brunch had to wait over an hour/one star".
One needs to utilize appropriate resources for varying situations. I find for instance Google less reliable for restaurant reviews where I'll utilize TripAdvisor or Opentable which have more experienced and (in my opinion) reputable reviewers than say Yelp, which is notoriously skewed toward reviews like where "the hostess was mean to me/one star" or "our party of seventeen with no reservation for brunch had to wait over an hour/one star".
Good point. Many a "patron" has used Yelp as a threat to restaurant owners
One needs to utilize appropriate resources for varying situations. I find for instance Google less reliable for restaurant reviews where I'll utilize TripAdvisor or Opentable which have more experienced and (in my opinion) reputable reviewers than say Yelp, which is notoriously skewed toward reviews like where "the hostess was mean to me/one star" or "our party of seventeen with no reservation for brunch had to wait over an hour/one star".
Yelpers hate everything, so you have to adjust their reviews accordingly. If you can find a restaurant with at least three stars on Yelp, go there at once; it will be the best meal you've ever had.
Yelpers hate everything, so you have to adjust their reviews accordingly. If you can find a restaurant with at least three stars on Yelp, go there at once; it will be the best meal you've ever had.
Funny, but that's a misrepresentation. I just 'Yelped' restaurants near a random address in downtown Buffalo, and the top 20 results were all either 4 or 4.5 stars. I'm sure 'Yelpers' can be more critical in other regions, but
Funny, but that's a misrepresentation. I just 'Yelped' restaurants near a random address in downtown Buffalo, and the top 20 results were all either 4 or 4.5 stars. I'm sure 'Yelpers' can be more critical in other regions, but
Yelp defaults to "most recommended" so no surprise the highest are on top. If you go by "most reviewed" you start seeing more with lower ratings, but also more opinions to judge by.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
