Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
I try to remove my feelings about his personal life from how I judge his work (but it's not easy!)
Anyway, I voted "I get about as many as I don't get."
Some of his stuff moves me, much of it really cracks me up, but sometimes his work can be a bit of a yawner. Some faves:
Sleeper
Hannah and Her Sisters
Crimes and Misdemeanors Not so much:
Deconstructing Harry
Mighty Aphrodite
I wish your survey was a little different, great director-yes, actor-??? weeelll hes just always Woody. We wouldnt want to see him as Hamlet now would we ? Love his movies, no apology. Perhaps because I was an Irish Catholic in love with a NYC jewish intellect many years ago, or maybe I just find him clever and entertaining.Dont know, but when he has a movie out, I pay attention. And Yes, the Mia/daughter thing =totally creepy, but I try not to judge or enter any opinion of celebrity life, they are all from another planet.
I try to remove my feelings about his personal life from how I judge his work (but it's not easy!)
Anyway, I voted "I get about as many as I don't get."
Some of his stuff moves me, much of it really cracks me up, but sometimes his work can be a bit of a yawner. Some faves:
Sleeper
Hannah and Her Sisters
Crimes and Misdemeanors Not so much:
Deconstructing Harry
Mighty Aphrodite
I agree about his personal life - it's hard to seperate the two. Also agree with your faves and hates. I'd add for faves Annie Hall, and hates Scoop!
P.S. I voted pervert! He married his then wife's adopted daughter - gross!
And Yes, the Mia/daughter thing =totally creepy, but I try not to judge or enter any opinion of celebrity life, they are all from another planet.
Right. It was totally creepy. But many great composers were total bastards. Many great painters were complete wack-jobs. Same with writers. I know of at least one fantastic film director still working today who is a completely despicable human being --- but his films are awesome.
You have to separate the art from the artist. The art should stand on its own. If the artist is even in the picture, he isn't very good at his job.
For people who look at Allen having a relationship with an adopted daughter while in a loving relationship with the mother, the concept is repulsive and creepy. Chances are the folks who see this came from traditional families, with core values of commitment. The show business reality is more commonly one of marriages and relationships for status, business reasons, and convenience rather than commitment. It was at least the third time around for both Mia and Woody, and they weren't committed enough to marry. The tragedy is that when Woody finally did find his muse, it happened to be the odds-out adopted daughter of Mia. Had she been a complete outsider, it would have just been another show business chapter.
What I think a lot of people have a hard time understanding is that the truly creative people don't get to be creative by constantly following the rules, whether those rules are the rules of the current art, of society, or anything else. They often live at or over the edge, and bring back insight that is otherwise missing to the mainstream. That insight is as valued as the rare spices brought back by outrageous explorers in the middle ages. The royalty valued the spices, even if they held the explorers in some disdain.
The bottom line is that Allen has brilliant wit and facility with the language, and a capability of introspection. For him to be able to expose his unprotected underside (prior to Farrow) was remarkable. For him to continue to do so afterward is even more so. I find him an interesting and somewhat self-torturing character.
What's Up, Tiger Lily? - B+
Take The Money & Run - A-
Bananas - B
Manhattan - B-
Annie Hall - A-
Scoop - B+
So I like most of what I've seen, which is not all that much. When I'm watching his movies I never think about his weird situation with his stepdaughter.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.