Will Jack White be remembered as a great song writer for our time?

[believe007]

Originally Posted by KidArizona

I agree about Edge. Remove him from the context of U2 and he's not that special, a lot of the open tunings etc people rave about are old hat

I agree; what he plays is way too easy & he relies a lot on the effects pedals.

Originally Posted by artemis agrotera

I really liked that doco, also made me respect Jack White even more, was impressed when he made that guitar.

Don't mind Edge, but he's no Jimmy Page

Jimmy Page reminds me of a Wizard, lol.
I really love him playing with Jack White- hope they do some music together

[loose cannon]

Overall I am a U2 fan. I kind of have lost interest in recent years, Edge was never a great guitarist. He has a unique style that works.

[believe007]

Originally Posted by loose cannon

Overall I am a U2 fan. I kind of have lost interest in recent years, Edge was never a great guitarist. He has a unique style that works.

I own everything U2 has ever done, I love U2....including Edge. But he just doesn't belong in the same league as Jack White & Jimmy Page as far as guitar legends go. Edge's style is unique & he adds some magic to U2- but Bono's voice & lyrics is the reason for my addiction to U2's music

[Pfhtex]

Would like to see J Mascis, Neil, and Jack again in It Might Get Louder.