Quote:
Originally Posted by agnostic soldier
This is like saying that if nine out of ten people believe in the Magical Quarter Gnome, then that means the Magical Quarter Gnome exists.
|
No, that doesn't mean they exist. BUT!...they would have just as much influence as if they did.
So, the fact they don't is moot, as respects "The Way Of The World".
MOF...Magical Quarter Gnomes could
actually exist, but without any objective/empirical proof of it. But if 9 out of 10 believed they didn't...they may as well not exist...as far as their "mojo" is concerned.
I've given this analogy several times before:
Regardless of all the scientific meteorological evidence against it...I have most people BELIEVING FOR SURE that it is going to snow 2 feet tomorrow in NY City, USA.
Now...how is the FACT that it isn't going to snow at all, let alone two feet, going to effect shovel sales, if most people
believe it's going to snow 2 feet anyway?
The people will act based upon
what they believe...even though it isn't true...and shovels will sell as if there was actually going to be 2 feet of snow.
Belief will dominate over truth to effect their conduct.
It doesn't matter if Theists are wrong and Atheists are right...or if Atheists are wrong and Theists are right...as respects the effect on the world that 98% of the people that have ever lived embraced Theism!
That small minority that are NonBelievers doesn't mean squat, even if they were/are totally "right"!
The FACT that the vast majority DID/DO believe GUARANTEES that it is what THEY think that is going to matter in this world!
As respects the effect on the world...anyone that thinks "objectively proven" is what matters...is WRONG about that!
What REALLY matters...is WHAT PEOPLE BELIEVE matters.
Ad populum only fails in the context of "Pedigree Logic"...it dominates just about everything else.
Anyone that wants an "objective fact" should get hip to
that one!