Who told (Abel and Cain) them to sacrifice ?!!!!who learned them to sacrifice ????? !!!! ADAM OR GOD ? (genesis, bible)

[insan777]

Both of them sacrifice !!! Cain and Abel ....they sacrificed suddenly to God !!! impossible

It must someone told them or order them to sacrifice ...(GOD or Adam)

who told them to sacrifice ?!!!!who learned them to sacrifice ????? !!!!

who told them to sacrifice ?!!!!who learned them to sacrifice ????? !!!! Adam or GOD ????

[Fred314X]

Genesis 4:3-4... "In the process of time, it came to pass that Cain brought the fruit of the ground an offering unto the Lord. And Abel, he also brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof."

In the process of time. In other words, the idea to make a sacrifice didn't suddenly hit them like a bolt of lightning. They had to have been taught. So maybe you might consider the idea that their parents had taught them something. Unless, of course, you have an agenda to propagate.

[DaniMae1]

They made it up as they went along I suppose. Just like the rest of the Bible!

[insan777]

Originally Posted by Fred314X

Genesis 4:3-4... "In the process of time, it came to pass that Cain brought the fruit of the ground an offering unto the Lord. And Abel, he also brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof."

In the process of time. In other words, the idea to make a sacrifice didn't suddenly hit them like a bolt of lightning. They had to have been taught. So maybe you might consider the idea that their parents had taught them something. Unless, of course, you have an agenda to propagate.

You said that "They had to have been taught" ....Who taught them to sacrifice ???? Their parents (ADAM and Eve or GOD)