Quote:
Originally Posted by Chukcha
I don't have a problem with Shaq over Kareem. Shaq's peak was as good as anybody. Prime Kareem got manhandled by Moses Malone on multiple occasions. Nobody could do that to prime Shaq. Kareem's advantage is longevity. But this isn't some one sided debate.
|
This is one of the reasons Shaq was ahead of Kareem on my list, but only slightly. As dominant an all-around player as Kareem was, I frankly doubt he could have done the same things in a match-up against Shaq's size and strength.
The Shaq-era NBA players Kareem most resembles in both build and style of play are David Robinson and Kevin Garnett.
Shaq's teams won most of its important match-ups against Robinson's teams (meaning championships were at stake), and the ones Robinson's teams won usually happened when Tim Duncan was playing at his peak, with the
combined ability of those twin towers being needed to somewhat neutralize Shaq.
With Kevin Garnett, as much of a beast as he was all over the floor during his and Shaq's parallel career primes, I don't think he technically even matched up against Shaq very often. He was a Hall-of-Fame All-Time Great 4-Man who was entirely too small to do anything against Shaq, who was just one position up at the 5, so KG's team's didn't give Shaq much trouble either.
So yeah, there's a legitimate argument for Shaq over Kareem.
Re-posting my list for reference:
My All-Time All-NBA Team as of 2017:
1st Team
PG- Magic Johnson
SG- Michael Jordan
SF- LeBron James
PF- Tim Duncan
C- Hakeem Olajuwon
2nd Team
PG- John Stockton
SG- Kobe Bryant
SF- Kevin Durant
PF- Larry Bird
C- Shaquille O'Neal
3rd Team
PG- Gary Payton
SG- Jerry West
SF- Scottie Pippen
PF- Kevin Garnett
C- Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
4th Team
PG- Stephen Curry
SG- Dwyane Wade
PF- Charles Barkley
PF- Karl Malone
C- Wilt Chamberlain