Hello slk45,
I was reading your post and the others to follow. Keep in mind, if you buy land that can be subdivided because the covenants say so, you still have to ck with the county to see if THEY allow it.
Can't tell you where to stay away from.
You're right to consider more than 1K per acre these days. The smaller the parcel the more per acre. If you are in the 20 acre size, you can find some decent land for about $1,500. to $2,000. per acre still.
For the person that can't find a lawyer in Santa Rosa, try the next town east in Tucamcari.
As for the "reputable" developer near Wagon Mound. Call his last 2 developments HOA boards for a reference.
I think you are on the right track by stating an area of weather, size and price range. Narrow that down to narrow down your location of choice then shop. Think about how far you are ok to being away from stores. The closer to a big town, the more $$ per acre. Nm is a big state and you can go crazy trying to see everything. I had seen where many people mentioned to you about the Quemado area. I sell land in Magdalena and Datil, went to school one year as a kid in Quemado, as my family ranches Pie Town so I do know the area somewhat.
All those towns are on hwy 60 from I25 to the Az. border. Usually about 30 minutes apart from each other. There are lots of subdivisons that were large ranches back in the day. Lots of property that can be bought. I believe Catron cnty. passed a new subdivision reg. saying the developer now has to gravel roads on the new subdivisions. There are lots of areas you can get bogged down in mud really bad. If you shop those areas or any really, off a dirt road, you really need to find out how those access roads are in the rain and winter. Even state hwy's can be dirt. I remember as a kid, I would be sent back to the ranch to get the old jeep to pull people out of the bar ditches off the state hwy. That road is better now.
Once you get into Datil and head west, you are getting pretty far removed from shopping, doctors and hospitals. Datil and Pie Town will get more snow in the winter than Magdalena. I would say all of the towns would have a pretty nice summers and not usually hotter than 90 in the summer. Magdalena seems to have the mildest temp swings. Less snow in the winter, summers are pretty nice, and it's closer to stores, Albuquerque and hospitals. I think all those towns are very pretty. I own land in Datil and north of Magdalena. Lots of Natl forest lands close to all those towns.
For milder weather I think the SW part of the state has it. You can go to yahoo.com and ck for weather highs/lows. And this city data website gives really good detailed info on diff. towns.
If you buy property in a subdivision with a HOA, which is most of what you will find. You should get the board contact info and find out how functional they really are. Do they take care of the roads? Are the members paying their dues?... Do they have money in the bank or broke? I know of one large development that is in pretty sorry shape and don't have the money to take care of the roads as so many people have not paid their dues. Mostly because of incompetance of the board not sending bills out and keeping up with owners and addresses.
My website is
United Country -Magdalena New Mexico. grouped by area. We have mountain properties in Datil pretty cheap, 20-30 acre properties north of Magdalena in the Natl. Forest, and 20-140 acre sizes at Windmill Ranches which is 22 miles north of Carrizozo(probably warmer than Magdalena in the summer) Prices are pretty good as they are first time resales. They got a good deal from the developer and they haven't been bought and resold already inflating the prices over and over. to view the listings by price range it's
New Mexico Real Estate - United Country New Mexico Property Connection.
NM is a great place to be. I've lived from Ca to Md and inbetween. Including OK. I'm staying put. The people are nice here, we have great weather and better prices than lots of dryer climates like Az and Ca. (so far) Come on to NM!
and yes, you can find really cheap property, and it could also be worthless. Don't buy sight unseen from those $3,000. properties or tax sales. goodluck.