I'm not remotely shocked. Did anyone really think that a few months doing hard labor with a family friend with no professional counseling whatsoever after he molested his sisters would help Josh establish healthy sexual boundaries?
He also has an OKCupid account:
Is This Josh Duggar's OkCupid Profile? Using the same screenname as the email address attached to the Ashley Madison account (complete with NWA = north west Arkansas), he swiped a photo from an up and coming model and posed as a single, monogamous man looking for casual sex. If you squint and look sideways, you can see how the model might be someone that Josh Duggar thinks he resembles.
The dates of the OKC account also line up with when he stopped paying for the first Ashley Madison account. You can see the actual account (and not just the article about it) if you have OKCupid at
joesmithsonnwa / 27 / Alexandria, Virginia | OkCupid.
OKCupid uses a matching algorithm based on mutual responses to a bunch of questions. You can see how others answered these questions if you both have answered the same ones. Some of Josh's are, well, disturbing. And if I wasn't convinced before, his answers certainly convince me that it's him.
Q: “Do you feel there are any circumstances in which a person is obligated to have sex with you?”
A: Yes
^That, friends, is what we call a rapey weed out question.
Q: “Do you think it’s possible for someone to be an Atheist and still have a solid framework by which to live?”
A: No
Q: "Have you been faithful in your past relationships?"
A: No
Q: "Do you need to sleep with someone before marrying them?"
A: Yes
Q: "If you are wrong, do you have a hard time apologizing?"
A: Yes
Q: "Rate your self confidence."
A: Very high
Q: "The idea of gay and lesbian couples having children is:"
A: Not acceptable
Q: "Do you believe that men should be the heads of their households?"
A: Yes
Q: "How would you react if someone IM'd you and quickly started talking about sex?"
A: Positively
Q: "Say you've started seeing someone you really like. As far as you're concerned, how long will it take before you have sex?"
A: 1-2 dates
Q: "In the line “Wherefore art thou Romeo?,” what does “wherefore” mean?"
A: Where
^He made that one mandatory, which makes me smugly amused.