Best Italian food in Miller Place, Mount Sinai, Rocky Point, Sound Beach area? (Nesconset: home, restaurant)

[Lancet71]

By my wifes request I would like an honest opinion. What is the best italian food in this general area (try to keep it around here and not further away). Base it on food quality, and prices that wont break the bank. Thanks!

[Gpsma]

Caruso's on Broadway in Rocky Point is very good. Looks like a pizzeria, which it is, but the dining room is restaurant quality. Good service, good food. Prices...not cheap but they wont break the bank.

[Crookhaven]

Originally Posted by Lancet71

By my wifes request I would like an honest opinion. What is the best italian food in this general area (try to keep it around here and not further away). Base it on food quality, and prices that wont break the bank. Thanks!

Im going with Carusos.
* Welcome to the Caruso's Restaurant Website * 41 Broadway Rocky Point NY *
Dont let the Pizzeria fool you.
Great value too.

Crooks

Check out Waynes other place too
Welcome to LaPlage Restaurant of Wading River

[Gpsma]

Another good place for Italian is Carnival. That's probably closer to Port Jeff. It's in the shopping center with Home Goods. Place is casual but very good. The dining area is in the back of the pizzeria and is quite large. Not a romantic place by any means but very nice inside. Good family type place with good food.

[Crookhaven]

Originally Posted by Gpsma

Another good place for Italian is Carnival. That's probably closer to Port Jeff. It's in the shopping center with Home Goods. Place is casual but very good. The dining area is in the back of the pizzeria and is quite large. Not a romantic place by any means but very nice inside. Good family type place with good food.

Great pick too

Awesome Calamari

Still slightly partial to Carusos for the Francese.

[OhBeeHave]

Originally Posted by Gpsma

Another good place for Italian is Carnival. That's probably closer to Port Jeff. It's in the shopping center with Home Goods. Place is casual but very good. The dining area is in the back of the pizzeria and is quite large. Not a romantic place by any means but very nice inside. Good family type place with good food.

I believe that's considered Port Jefferson Station.

[Gpsma]

I'm sure Walter will be around to tell us EXACTLY where it is.

[Lancet71]

Originally Posted by Gpsma

I'm sure Walter will be around to tell us EXACTLY where it is.

On Nesconset Hwy is PJS.North of the tracks becomes Port Jefferson. Carnival is good though,but their heroes last week weren't as good as usual.

[NYTom]

Why don't they just open up a Rocky Point Forum for crying out loud!

[Gpsma]

Great Idea!!! Everyone just loves Rocky Point. Don't you?