Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
start on SOME day .. SOME day not the EXACT day name ,
unless it is a coincident that all the countries and nations started on the same day name as life started coincidently as non believers believes ,
or may be there was only one nation and then all other generated nations followed it.
I gae the reasons why people have a seven day week and days measured by the sising and setting of the sun. Thus there is no reason to suppose there was once one super -culture that taught everyone the same reckoning and in fact all the evidence, historical and archaeological sugests that there no unified cultures before around 10,000 let alone one that taught one system of reckoning to all humanity.
The Abrahamic 'Babel' story has no credibility and indded tends to refute the idea because, if all peoples were scattered and developed different languages, why didn't they develop different weeks and days? Because the sun and moon was the basis for the reckoning.
All the evidence is against your argument that weeks staring on a Friday, or Saturday or (significantly) for Judaism, on a Sunday, somehow validates the Quran claim that Allah 'gave' the day.
Do you know what names the Africans of Southern Africa gave to mountains and water and all the animals?
Or the Koi and the San? Do you know their names for animals?
Did those Africans and Koi and San have a seven day week? Did they rest on the Sabbath or Sunday?
Do you even know why there is a Sabbath and a Sunday - the day of rest - given by god that are different days? Which day do you use?
not necessarily the Koi or southern Africa , look at France , Italy , Germany , UK .. etc.
Why do they have different language ?
there are two possibilities for this
1- Adam was giving all the language from Allah
2- Adam was giving only one language and then by time many language were diverted from the main language.
And He taught Adam all the names... The Holy Quran 2:31
If the seven day week is adopted, the days will always coincide with lunar phases. Since there is only one moon, the same moon for everyone, this is to be expected.
However, where in the original story of Adam and Eve is the day of creation named?
The Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) said
The best day on which the sun rises is Friday.
On it Adam was created,
on it he was admitted to Paradise and on it he was expelled therefrom.”
I gae the reasons why people have a seven day week and days measured by the sising and setting of the sun. Thus there is no reason to suppose there was once one super -culture that taught everyone the same reckoning and in fact all the evidence, historical and archaeological sugests that there no unified cultures before around 10,000 let alone one that taught one system of reckoning to all humanity.
The Abrahamic 'Babel' story has no credibility and indded tends to refute the idea because, if all peoples were scattered and developed different languages, why didn't they develop different weeks and days? Because the sun and moon was the basis for the reckoning.
All the evidence is against your argument that weeks staring on a Friday, or Saturday or (significantly) for Judaism, on a Sunday, somehow validates the Quran claim that Allah 'gave' the day.
not every thing is found in history and it is impossible
The Quran gives facts about things that the others just invent theories about them.
The first is the wrong question - it is why should different people have the same language? In fact even people who begin with the same language can two or three centuries later, have a different or changed one.
There is no need for a mythical tale about One person originating the One language everybody spoke, let alone another mythical tale to explain we we none of us speak it.
For the second, Quran quotes claiming that Friday is special even though it isn't to other people is a waste of everyone's time.
not necessarily the Koi or southern Africa , look at France , Italy , Germany , UK .. etc.
Why do they have different language ?
there are two possibilities for this
1- Adam was giving all the language from Allah
2- Adam was giving only one language and then by time many language were diverted from the main language.
And He taught Adam all the names... The Holy Quran 2:31
So you have tried to Fix the discussion beforehand and with two Permitted options that are both wrong.
.
No Harry Diogenes said that there are more than two possibilities and he did not identify even one .
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
There are more than two possibilities.
