Quote:
Originally Posted by blacknight04
If you don't want people to assume then give the thread a better title. At least from what i gathered, the study is saying ALL immigrants are costing the U.S taxpayer money. If you read otherwise, then please post some quotes from the study proving me wrong.
|
It's a 72 page study which you obviously did not read too closely. It deals with the top governmental agencies currently affected by immigration, legal and illegal.
Not surprisingly, the majority of costs are in various areas which would deal primarily with illegal immigration and the cost of the political refugees from various nations.
1. Department of Agriculture
2. Department of Justice
3. Department of Commerce
4. Department of Labor
5. Department of Defense
6. Department of State
7. Department of Education
8. Department of the Interior
9. Department of Energy/Environmental Protection Agency
10.Department of Transportation
11.Department of Health and Human Services
12.Social Security Administration
13.Department of Homeland Security
Refugees have already emerged as a large and growing fiscal burden. They are immediately eligible for various government welfare programs, and the evidence is clear that they stay on them. Moreover, they start chain-migrating relatives under the “family reunification” provisions of current law.
There are already millions of immigrant refugess in the United States and we are now set to receive the following from Iraq alone:
* 75,000 Iraqi refugees by 2016 under the Somali refugee scenario
* 500,000 Iraqi refugees by 2016 under the Bosnian scenario
* 560,000 Iraqi refugees by 2036 under the Vietnam scenario
* 2.5 million Iraqi refugees by 2044 under the Cuban scenario
In recent testimony before the House Judiciary Committee, Robert Rector estimated the fiscal deficit of households headed by immigrants who lack a high school diploma—a reasonable proxy for refugees.
http://judiciary.house.gov/media/pdfs/Rector070517.pdf (broken link)
Rector finds that the average uneducated immigrant household:
* Receives $30,164 in government benefits
* Pays $10,573 in government taxes
* Generates a fiscal deficit
Many of us in this country know the deteriments of legal immigration when employers are using various loopholes in the immigration laws order to bring in educated immigrants who will work for less than their American counterparts thus driving down the white collar wage base even further than it has already fallen.
If we continue to accept legal immigration at current rates, the natural and unrenewable resources of the United States of America will soon diminish beyond capability to support the number of people that have decided to make their homes here. Experts already predict that the Southwest will completely run out of water within the next 50 years. So why don't we invite even MORE people into the country and see if we can't reduce our water viability by another 25 years.
I'm not going to go wading through the 72 pages again in order to provide you with some feel good quotes about the benefits of legal immigration. There are many advantages to welcoming those who love and respect this country enough to go through the system to become citizens. But the disadvantages are numerous as well.
There is no doubt that immigrants have contributed to the greatness of this country. Without the contribution of immigrants, America would have never become the amazing country that it is. Yet simply because we accepted immigrants in large numbers at the beginning of the 20th century does not mean that we can continue to sustain exorbitant additions to our current population. One would have to be extremely shortsighted to fail to grasp such a simple notion.
I think that I've proven that I did my research. Instead of merely glancing at the title page, or getting hung up on the title of my thread, perhaps you should actually sit down and read the entire study and stop expecting me to do it for you. You might actually learn something and you may find that rather than being a snooze, this study is actually quite interesting and informative.