Florida Judge Used Obama's Own Words To Rule Against ObamaCare (Congress, regular)

[Jill61]

YAY, another Obama bashing thread!

Doesn't matter that the judge was flat out wrong in using that quote as any kind of legal authority (since it clearly wasn't).

Doesn't matter that the judge just completely ignored Wickard and Lopez and their actual legal authority covering this Law.

Let's just make fun of our President! Yippee!!

How pathetic.

[Houston3]

Originally Posted by Winter_Sucks

Legislating from the bench.

That's more in line with what liberal judges do....

[KoobleKar]

Originally Posted by Jill61

Doesn't matter that the judge was flat out wrong in using that quote as any kind of legal authority (since it clearly wasn't).

Did you forget your coffee this morning?

The quoted part of the original post CLEARLY states that this was used in a FOOTNOTE within his ruling.

Please pay closer attention next time.

[Frank DeForrest]

Originally Posted by Jill61

YAY, another Obama bashing thread!

Doesn't matter that the judge was flat out wrong in using that quote as any kind of legal authority (since it clearly wasn't).

Doesn't matter that the judge just completely ignored Wickard and Lopez and their actual legal authority covering this Law.

Let's just make fun of our President! Yippee!!

How pathetic.

Wonders how the federal government forcing quotas on wheat farmers as means of price control applies to mandating everyone purchase health care insurance

The rest of your post is

[SourD]

Originally Posted by Jill61

YAY, another Obama bashing thread!

Doesn't matter that the judge was flat out wrong in using that quote as any kind of legal authority (since it clearly wasn't).

Doesn't matter that the judge just completely ignored Wickard and Lopez and their actual legal authority covering this Law.

Let's just make fun of our President! Yippee!!

How pathetic.

Holy *****, you really said this? Do you live under or near high tension wires?

[KoobleKar]

Yes, nothing in Wickard - Lopez pertains to forcing anyone (under penalty) to BUY something they may not want to purchase.

The Commerce Clause has NEVER been applied in such a manner before.

[Jill61]

Originally Posted by Frank DeForrest

Wonders how the federal government forcing quotas on wheat farmers as means of price control applies to mandating everyone purchase health care insurance

The rest of your post is

You clearly don't understand Wickard. I've already discussed it in detail in 2 other threads that are actually about the ruling. I'm not going to rehash it here in a thread that's nothing but a bash President Obama thread.

Originally Posted by KoobleKar

Yes, nothing in Wickard - Lopez pertains to forcing anyone (under penalty) to BUY something they may not want to purchase.

The Commerce Clause has NEVER been applied in such a manner before.

Wrong. But I'm not surprised.

[KoobleKar]

Originally Posted by Jill61

I'm not going to rehash it here in a thread that's nothing but a bash President Obama thread.

Wrong. But I'm not surprised.

Then it's up to you to PROVE it.

I'm quite SURE I'm right.

[Jill61]

[quote=KoobleKar;17722260]

Originally Posted by KoobleKar

Then it's up to you to PROVE it.

I'm quite SURE I'm right.

Had you not missed my point, you'd know I've already discussed the applicability of Wickard in the threads that are actually about the ruling.

Feel free to be quite SURE that brown is blue, too. Won't make it any more true.

[Pretzelogik]

WTF Win the future. "Change isn't easy." "Make no mistake." "It won't happen overnight." communism takes time "Let me be clear."... no.....on second thought let me change my mind.