Property valuation of Windsor Way, Twinsburg, OH: 9582, 9593, 9598, 9605, 9606, 9614, 9615 (tax assessments)
Other nearby streets: Darien Lane (1) 
Darien Lane (2)
Granby Circle (1)
Granby Circle (2)
Windsor Way
Darien Lane (2)
Granby Circle (1)
Granby Circle (2)
Windsor Way
Listed properties vs overall distribution of properties in Twinsburg, OH:
Advertisements
9582 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: RICHARD L CONKLIN
Building value: $228,480
Land value: $72,940
Total value for property: $301,420
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,786 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,381 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $18,260
Living area of additions: 24 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,380 square feet
Heat/air value: $4,040
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $223,640
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $223,640
Replacement cost new value: $237,920
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,145 square feet
Land frontage: 103 feet
Land depth: 215 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.15
Square footage: 22,145 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: RICHARD L CONKLIN
Building value: $228,480
Land value: $72,940
Total value for property: $301,420
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,786 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,381 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $18,260
Living area of additions: 24 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,380 square feet
Heat/air value: $4,040
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $223,640
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $223,640
Replacement cost new value: $237,920
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,145 square feet
Land frontage: 103 feet
Land depth: 215 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.15
Square footage: 22,145 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: DEVELOPMENT PSRTNERS L P GRANITE
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 10/19/1999
Price: $297,900
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: RICHARD L CONKLIN
Validity: Valid
9593 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: VIDYASAGAR PASUPNETI
Building value: $218,520
Land value: $71,670
Total value for property: $290,190
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,561 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,096 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $38,560
Living area of additions: 369 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,100 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,440
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $215,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $215,400
Replacement cost new value: $229,150
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 23,038 square feet
Land frontage: 96 feet
Land depth: 240 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.17
Square footage: 23,040 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: VIDYASAGAR PASUPNETI
Building value: $218,520
Land value: $71,670
Total value for property: $290,190
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,561 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,096 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $38,560
Living area of additions: 369 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,100 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,440
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $215,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $215,400
Replacement cost new value: $229,150
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 23,038 square feet
Land frontage: 96 feet
Land depth: 240 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.17
Square footage: 23,040 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: GRANITE DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS L.P.
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 10/28/1999
Price: $278,945
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: VIDYASAGAR PASUPNETI & UMA PASUPNETI
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 05/20/2004
Old owner name: VIDYASAGAR PASUPNETI & UMA PASUPNETI
New owner name: VIDYASAGAR PASUPNETI
9598 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: MICHAEL I STEPHENS
Building value: $284,360
Land value: $75,220
Total value for property: $359,580
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,578 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 966 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $59,360
Living area of additions: 646 square feet
Adjusted area: 970 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,160
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $281,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $281,400
Replacement cost new value: $237,590
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,228 square feet
Land frontage: 117 feet
Land depth: 190 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.11
Square footage: 22,230 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: MICHAEL I STEPHENS
Building value: $284,360
Land value: $75,220
Total value for property: $359,580
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,578 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 966 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $59,360
Living area of additions: 646 square feet
Adjusted area: 970 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,160
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $281,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $281,400
Replacement cost new value: $237,590
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,228 square feet
Land frontage: 117 feet
Land depth: 190 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.11
Square footage: 22,230 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: GRANITE DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS L.P.
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 09/30/1999
Price: $338,100
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: MICHAEL I STEPHENS & CARLENE STEPHENS
Validity: Valid
9605 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: BRIAN E LIPPERT
Building value: $286,450
Land value: $71,880
Total value for property: $358,330
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,796 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,075 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $63,770
Living area of additions: 646 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,080 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,400
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $282,470
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $282,470
Replacement cost new value: $254,660
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,498 square feet
Land frontage: 100 feet
Land depth: 225 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.15
Square footage: 22,500 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: BRIAN E LIPPERT
Building value: $286,450
Land value: $71,880
Total value for property: $358,330
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,796 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,075 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $63,770
Living area of additions: 646 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,080 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,400
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $282,470
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $282,470
Replacement cost new value: $254,660
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,498 square feet
Land frontage: 100 feet
Land depth: 225 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.15
Square footage: 22,500 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: GRANITE DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS L.P.
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 08/11/1999
Price: $332,100
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: DOUGLAS A BATES & ANGELA D BATES
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 03/28/2001
Price: $341,000
Old owner name: DOUGLAS A BATES & ANGELA D BATES
New owner name: MICHAEL J CIANI & DAIL A CIANI
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 06/22/2006
Price: $395,000
Old owner name: MICHAEL J CIANI & DAIL A CIANI
New owner name: BRIAN E LIPPERT
Validity: Valid
9606 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: DAVID D ALBRIGHT
Building value: $265,100
Land value: $68,260
Total value for property: $333,360
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,487 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Recreational room area: 1,658 square feet
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,161 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $33,430
Living area of additions: 165 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,160 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,570
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $261,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $261,400
Replacement cost new value: $243,930
Recreational Room Value: $12,500
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 18,334 square feet
Land frontage: 95 feet
Land depth: 193 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.12
Square footage: 18,335 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: DAVID D ALBRIGHT
Building value: $265,100
Land value: $68,260
Total value for property: $333,360
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 2,487 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Recreational room area: 1,658 square feet
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,161 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $33,430
Living area of additions: 165 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,160 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,570
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $261,400
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $261,400
Replacement cost new value: $243,930
Recreational Room Value: $12,500
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 18,334 square feet
Land frontage: 95 feet
Land depth: 193 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.12
Square footage: 18,335 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: GRANITE DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS L.P.
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 07/22/1999
Price: $313,400
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: DAVID D ALBRIGHT & MICHELE L ALBRIGHT
Validity: Valid
9614 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: SYLVIA RIGOL TRUSTEE
Building value: $276,230
Land value: $76,250
Total value for property: $352,480
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 3,016 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of full bathrooms: 3
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 13
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,214 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $56,430
Living area of additions: 588 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,210 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,680
Plumbing value: $8,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $273,320
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $273,320
Replacement cost new value: $264,330
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,773 square feet
Land frontage: 118 feet
Land depth: 193 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.12
Square footage: 22,774 square feet
Reason: Miscellaneous reasons
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: SYLVIA RIGOL TRUSTEE
Building value: $276,230
Land value: $76,250
Total value for property: $352,480
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 3,016 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of full bathrooms: 3
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 13
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,214 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $56,430
Living area of additions: 588 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,210 square feet
Heat/air value: $3,680
Plumbing value: $8,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $273,320
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $273,320
Replacement cost new value: $264,330
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Percent Construction Complete: $100
Land area: 22,773 square feet
Land frontage: 118 feet
Land depth: 193 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.12
Square footage: 22,774 square feet
Reason: Miscellaneous reasons
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sales:
-
Sale date: 12/28/1998
Price: $1,011,300
Old owner name: DEVELOPMENT PARTNER S L P GRANITE
New owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 07/30/1999
Price: $335,000
Old owner name: HOMES OF OHIO CORPORATION PULTE
New owner name: WOLFGANG F RIGOL & SYLVIA RIGOL
Validity: Valid
-
Sale date: 06/21/2001
Old owner name: SYLVIA RIGOL & WOLFGANG F RIGOL
New owner name: SYLVIA RIGOL
-
Sale date: 06/21/2001
Old owner name: SYLVIA RIGOL
New owner name: SYLVIA RIGOL TRUSTEE
9615 Windsor Way
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: MARYBETH WILLIAMS
Building value: $291,380
Land value: $76,570
Total value for property: $367,950
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 3,840 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Recreational room area: 700 square feet
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,384 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $90,210
Living area of additions: 1,072 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,380 square feet
Heat/air value: $4,040
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $291,380
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $291,380
Replacement cost new value: $322,890
Recreational Room Value: $5,300
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Land area: 22,498 square feet
Land frontage: 125 feet
Land depth: 180 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.09
Square footage: 22,500 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sale date: 11/30/1999
Price: $323,230
Twinsburg, OH 44087
Find on map >>
Owner: MARYBETH WILLIAMS
Building value: $291,380
Land value: $76,570
Total value for property: $367,950
Class: Residential
Land use: Single Family Dwelling, Platted Lot
Living area: 3,840 square feet
Exterior wall: Aluminum/vinyl
Style: Colonial
Year property was built: 1999
Total number of rooms: 8
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of family rooms: 1
Number of full bathrooms: 2
Number of half bathrooms: 1
Total number of plumbing fixtures: 10
Basement: Full
Type of heating: Central air condition
Fuel Type: Gas
Attic: No
Recreational room area: 700 square feet
Prefabricated fireplace: Yes
Main ground floor area: 1,384 square feet
Condition: Good
Replacement cost new value of additions: $90,210
Living area of additions: 1,072 square feet
Adjusted area: 1,380 square feet
Heat/air value: $4,040
Plumbing value: $5,000
Replacement cost new less depreciation value: $291,380
Adjusted replacement cost new less depreciation value: $291,380
Replacement cost new value: $322,890
Recreational Room Value: $5,300
Wood Fireplace Value: $2,000
Land area: 22,498 square feet
Land frontage: 125 feet
Land depth: 180 feet
Land depth table: 150 feet
Land depth factor: 1.09
Square footage: 22,500 square feet
Reason: Reappraisal
Assessments for tax year: 2009
Sale date: 11/30/1999
Price: $323,230
Other nearby streets: Darien Lane (1)
Darien Lane (2)
Granby Circle (1)
Granby Circle (2)
Windsor Way
Darien Lane (2)
Granby Circle (1)
Granby Circle (2)
Windsor Way
Recent posts about Twinsburg, Ohio on our local forum with over 2,400,000 registered users. Twinsburg is mentioned 107 times on our forum:
 | Macedonia or Twinsburg (2 replies) |
| Military relocating me to Twinsburg (8 replies) |
| What is Twinsburg like? (11 replies) |
| 23, moving to Northern Ohio and need advice badly! (10 replies) |
| West side (Brecksville, North Royalton) Vs. East (Stow, Cuyahoga Falls) (9 replies) |
| Romantic restaurant for Valentine's Day? (5 replies) |
Settings
X
Recently Added Photos
Twinsburg, OH
Twinsburg, OH
Twinsburg, OH
Twinsburg, OH
Middletown, OH
Middletown, OH
Lisbon, OH
Parma, OH
Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Rocky River, OH
Mayfield Heights, OH
Rocky River, OH
Request disassociating your name from street-level assessment address
Recent home sales, price trends, and home value evaluator powered by Onboard Informatics
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Some parts © 2024 Advameg, Inc.
Compilation, repackaging, or reproduction prohibited. Users are forewarned that it is incumbent upon them to verify information with the responsible state agency. Advameg, Inc. does not guarantee the data presented is up-to-date nor does it assume responsibility for updating it. Therefore any names, owners or addresses may have changed. Use of any information published here to contact the persons might be prohibited by the law.