Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
At least the instant eliminations tonight made sense. The two booted weren't very good, and they were both off tune.
Spoiler
Hated James Massone tonight, weak voice, off tune. On Adam's team I thought either of the guys should leave. They were both bad, and happy with Pip's elimination.
I have grown more towards Cheesa each week. I think she's incredible.
Wasn't crazy about Juliet tonight but I think it was the song. Don't like her new movie star'ish look. But Catherine on Adam's team looked very nice.
On Adam's team I'm leaning towards Mathai (did I spell that right?).
I guess this is why we're a free country ... I don't "get" Cheesa or Mathai at all! I thought Cheesa was AWFUL on the Whitney song... missed notes, too strained...just awful. I only caught the end of Mathai but don't care for her either.
Of the group I saw I liked Tony Lucca.... it practically killed Christina to say something nice about him, didn't it?
I admit I don't follow why the judges still get to eliminate people...once "America votes" shouldn't it be that way the rest of the way?? It seems so dumb to me to put a singer's number on the screen when in the next 5 minutes they may be out!
I guess this is why we're a free country ... I don't "get" Cheesa or Mathai at all! I thought Cheesa was AWFUL on the Whitney song... missed notes, too strained...just awful. I only caught the end of Mathai but don't care for her either.
Of the group I saw I liked Tony Lucca.... it practically killed Christina to say something nice about him, didn't it?
I admit I don't follow why the judges still get to eliminate people...once "America votes" shouldn't it be that way the rest of the way?? It seems so dumb to me to put a singer's number on the screen when in the next 5 minutes they may be out!
I agreed with pretty much everything you said. I missed the first 40 or so minutes of the show, and showed up just in time to hear Mathai butcher the end of her song. I never got Cheesa's appeal, because she's just another 'big voice singer' who seems to be a dime a dozen in competitions like this and karaoke bars...and IMO she isn't the best of the big voices. And the Whitney song just proved it to me. You don't sing a song like that unless you can knock it out of the park, and she may have just hit a pop fly.
I thought Tony was AWESOME. It's funny, because right when they were talking about what song to pick, I turned to my hubby and said "he should sing one of Christina's....maybe Genie in a Bottle." I hit the idea, but missed the pop-tart.
I'm not a fan of Juliet, but I can't deny she gives it her all. And going back to listen to Jamar and Katrina...I think it Tony and Juliet for the vote.
I don't like the judges elimination, either. I don't mind the save as much, but just the flat out elimination sucks. I wouldn't mind if the let the judges opinion weight the popular vote, like the do reducing 2 to 1.
I agreed with CeeLo getting rid of James Massone, but probably would have kept Pip and ditched Mathai. I thought Pip did the best job he's done last night.
I'd sort of forgotten about Katrina and enjoyed her performance. Juliet nails the female rocker thing but don't know if that's enough to win.
I guess this is why we're a free country ... I don't "get" Cheesa or Mathai at all! I thought Cheesa was AWFUL on the Whitney song... missed notes, too strained...just awful. I only caught the end of Mathai but don't care for her either.
Of the group I saw I liked Tony Lucca.... it practically killed Christina to say something nice about him, didn't it?
I admit I don't follow why the judges still get to eliminate people...once "America votes" shouldn't it be that way the rest of the way?? It seems so dumb to me to put a singer's number on the screen when in the next 5 minutes they may be out!
That IS funny. Because I don't find any talent in Tony Lucca at all. He just does "nothing" for me. But the audience hears/sees something in him that I don't.
My favorite is still Chris.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
... I don't "get" Cheesa or Mathai at all! I thought Cheesa was AWFUL on the Whitney song... missed notes, too strained...just awful. I only caught the end of Mathai but don't care for her either. 
