Who are your own personal top 5 QB's All Time Greats?

[seamusnh]

Originally Posted by susancruzs

A little off topic:

Me, too! I don't dwell on losses but 2014 NFC Championship loss to Seahawks, Packers should have won, played the Pats in the SB. They beat the Patriots during that season, it would have been a great game!

Patriots fans would welcome a SB with the Packer. Brady vs. Rodgers... two of the top NFL franchises... revenge for '96...

[Tall Traveler]

1. Brady.
2. Montana
3. Bradshaw
4. Peyton Manning
5. John Elway

[G1..]

Originally Posted by DaveinMtAiry

Well now that is beyond ridiculous. But just because someone for whatever reason felt the need to put Michael Vick on the list does not mean Eli belongs in the company of Joe Montana and Tom Brady.

Until Tom can beat Eli in that big game ,there is always a space for Eli.

[warren zee]

Im A Jets fan, but why does everyone leave out Dan Marino. Just because he had crap teams. He has to be in the top five. I would have him ahead of Peyton Manning. If you put Marino on Pittsburgh, Denver, Indianapolis, even my Jets in those days, he would have 4 or 5 super bowls. And this is coming from a Jets fan who always hated him, because we didn't draft him