If you support the redifinition of marriage, do you support consensual incest? (state, claim)

[Sophiasmommy]

Originally Posted by mlassoff

Not as small as starting a poll to bash gay people.

Who has done that?

Are you so insecure that you desperately need everyone's approval, all of the time?

[Sophiasmommy]

Originally Posted by DewDropInn

Soooo..... OP: How often do you find yourself thinking about incest?

Go to store. Pick up bread. Take car in for tire rotation. Think about incest.....

Not as often as I think about double standards and hypocrisy. You?

[filihok]

Originally Posted by Sophiasmommy

And yet, despite the ability to spell correctly you were so easily confused by a misplaced "s". Odd.

Why do you think he/she was confused? He/she clearly identified 'incest' as the word that you intended to spell.

[HollandUSA]

If only we could back to the good old days right?

Google Image Result for http://content.artofmanliness.com/uploads/2008/06/a5fatherknowsbestcast.jpg

[MIKEETC]

Originally Posted by Sophiasmommy

Thread title says it all. If you support redefining marriage, do you support a mother marrying her daughter, if they both are consenting adults? Or a father and son? Why or why not? Thanks

What two consenting adults do with each other is none of my business.

[my support is irrelevant]

[Sophiasmommy]

Originally Posted by filihok

Why do you think he/she was confused? He/she clearly identified 'incest' as the word that you intended to spell.

Here's what he/she wrote in post #3:

The poll would be clearer if the OP had spelled Incest correctly.

[HollandUSA]

Originally Posted by MIKEETC

What two consenting adults do with each other is none of my business.

[my support is irrelevant]

God needs you to smite them.

[Sophiasmommy]

Originally Posted by HollandUSA

If only we could back to the good old days right?

Google Image Result for http://content.artofmanliness.com/uploads/2008/06/a5fatherknowsbestcast.jpg

Just outta curiosity, why do Neo Progs have such an issue with that? Why are you against a stable family unit with a mom and a dad?

[FinsterRufus]

Originally Posted by Sophiasmommy

No, I am talking about two grown ADULTS who are consenting. Who are you to force your views on two people who want to marry one another?

You were talking about mother/daughter and son/son.

Generally, those two people had a minor/guardian relationship BEFORE one of them became an adult, which negates the idea that the child, REGARDLESS OF THEIR AGE, is truly consenting, given that they would have at some point had a relationship with the parent as an AUTHORITY figure.

Same between prison guards and prisoners, hostages and kidnappers, prisoners and captors. When someone is or has been in a position of authority against someone who was helpless against their power at one point, it makes the whole concept of consent VERY MURKY INDEED.

[Sophiasmommy]

Originally Posted by filihok

You haven't answered your own question.

If you support to redefinition of marriage, to 1 man and 1 woman, do you also support consensual incest?

I don't agree with you, that's why I can't answer it. One man/one woman has been the historical definition of marriage more than any other definition. If gay marriage has always been the norm, as it appears that you're trying to imply, than why hasn't it always been accepted? And again, if you support same sex marriage, do you support consensual incest marriage?