Man charged with first-degree murder for abortion doctor's death (polls, independent, program)

[arctichomesteader]

Originally Posted by FinkieMcGee

Comparing people to the nazis is a pretty terrible argument, fyi. It's called Godwin's law. How about actual engaging the argument instead of framing things in moral black and white? What Tiller did is in a gigantic moral grey zone, arguing otherwise is disingenuous..

In this case it's a very appropriate comparison. The abortion movement (actually an arm of the eugenics movement) inspired the Nazis, and Sanger (founder planned parenthood) praised the Nazis. And the reasons cited for justifying the abortions in this case is precisely the sort of thing the Nazis and other eugenicists would cite.

[newtoli]

Originally Posted by arctichomesteader

In this case it's a very appropriate comparison. The abortion movement (actually an arm of the eugenics movement) inspired the Nazis, and Sanger (founder planned parenthood) praised the Nazis. And the reasons cited for justifying the abortions in this case is precisely the sort of thing the Nazis and other eugenicists would cite.

So, you think the woman in the article should have been forced to carry to term? For what purpose, exactly?

[idahogie]

Originally Posted by allydriver

Your post made me want to take a shower.

What kind of sick person could paint a doctor who performed 60,000 abortions a year and made over a million plus doing it, a brave martyr?

And I'm not even a pro lifer.

Oh really? That's 164 abortions/day, every day.

I think you'd better go take that shower and think about reality a bit.

[arctichomesteader]

Originally Posted by newtoli

And what service are those fisherman providing to the public, other than some delicious crab legs? Are people shooting at them for doing their job?

Personally, a woman's health trumps crab legs, IMO.

None of his murders were necessary to save any woman's life that I'm aware of.

More than just crab fishing going on...in countries like Japan (little land for farming) a large part of their food comes from that fishing...

[newtoli]

Originally Posted by idahogie

Oh really? That's 164 abortions/day, every day.

I think you'd better go take that shower and think about reality a bit.

Math wins.

Kansas had a little over 12k abortions total performed last year, and Tiller's clinic wasn't the only one in the State... so yeah 60k is a little wacky.

[Stac2007]

Originally Posted by idahogie

Oh really? That's 164 abortions/day, every day.

I think you'd better go take that shower and think about reality a bit.

It is true, he did over sixty thousand abortion during his time as a doctor/baby killer.

[newtoli]

Originally Posted by Stac2007

It is true, he did over sixty thousand abortion during his time as a doctor/baby killer.

If your wife was pregnant, and the pregnancy threatened her life, would you force her to carry to term?

If your wife was pregnant, and it turned out the fetus had ancephaly and would die during childbirth, would you force her to carry to term?

Those are the services he provided to women and was murdered for.

[karfar]

Originally Posted by Stac2007

It is true, he did over sixty thousand abortion during his time as a doctor/baby killer.

Well according to another poster, he performed 60,000 abortions a year. So which is it?

[Stac2007]

Originally Posted by karfar

Well according to another poster, he performed 60,000 abortions a year. So which is it?

It was over the course of his career.

[Currency Pair Crocodile]

Originally Posted by newtoli

If your wife was pregnant, and the pregnancy threatened her life, would you force her to carry to term?

If your wife was pregnant, and it turned out the fetus had ancephaly and would die during childbirth, would you force her to carry to term?

Those are the services he provided to women and was murdered for.

Yeah, 100% of Tiller's antics were on life-threatened women.