Quote:
Originally Posted by YourWakeUpCall
A police officer can "ask" anything. There's a difference between asking and demanding under color of authority. Choose you words carefully.
|
I disagree. Where he has no legal authority to ask for something, he should not be able to even ask. When a police officer "asks" for something it's too fine of a line to say they are not demanding it.
Quote:
Your poor selection of words notwithstanding, a police officer can absolutely demand your ID if you've done nothing wrong. He/she may have probable cause to believe you have committed a crime. Said probable cause may be based on facts and information of which you are unaware. Probably cause is not irrefutable evidence and sometimes the information the police officer is using to establish probable cause is incorrect. None of which changes that fact the he/she has probable cause and is therefore allowed to demand that you identify yourself. This scenario may or may not have applied to this particular case, but to state that a police officer has no right to ask you to identify yourself because you've done nothing wrong is demonstrably incorrect and is going to get you in trouble some day. You aren't one of those "sovereign citizen" goof balls, are you? Their incredibly misunderstanding of their rights is breathtaking.
|
I had already covered this. They must have a probable cause they can express. "I'm suspicious" is not enough. If there was a murder and the suspect is described as a young very tall male and you are in a car fleeing town and are 22 and 6 foot 5, then they can ask.
I posted the Supreme Court ruling. I also stated he had "no business" not "no right".